A Response to My Critics About the 'Homophobic' Language in Battlefield 3
By Dr. Eleanor Vance | Published on January 01, 0001
On Monday, I wrote about homophobic language in Battlefield 3. I thought I had sufficiently unpacked the words I quoted from the game’s multiplayer dialogue in order to make my point clear. https://kotaku.com/the-unquestioned-homophobia-in-battlefield-3-5876445 Perhaps not. Unpacking bias in language is about context and association. It’s basically a semiotic exercise, pulling sentences apart and figuring out what the words mean underneath the words themselves. It’s slow and tedious and often frustrating, and I had thought not to belabor the point any more than necessary. I erred in the wrong direction, because people seem to think the lines “I’m getting fucked up the ass over here!” and “Fuck, I’m getting my shit pushed in here!” in Battlefield 3’s multiplayer are expressing fear of rape instead of homophobia. Before I explain why that’s not the case, some background is in order. I am white, male and straight. I am the definition of cultural privilege in the United States. Social justice activists like to argue that bias affects everyone, but I maintain a sneaking suspicion that’s more theory than reality. I could, at any moment, decide to pay absolutely no attention to the racism, sexism, or homophobia embedded in the culture and language around me, and my life would not change one whit. It takes effort for me to notice prejudice because I have to look for it. I suspect my efforts at being sensitive to prejudice are why I finally realized how this dialogue in Battlefield 3 was homophobic. If you would like to argue that the soldiers in Battlefield 3‘s multiplayer are conveying fear of being raped in general, which is not homophobic, versus fear of being raped by men, which is decidedly homophobic, you are arguing that they are expressing fear of being raped by someone other than a man. In other words, you are arguing that they may be expressing fear of being raped by a woman in this specific context. Technically, those lines could be referring to men and women. Anal sex is not strictly a gay activity. That is absolutely correct. However, in American culture, anal sex is linked to or often representative of gay sex. Saying that anal sex is a homophobic reference in this specific instance and context is not the same thing as saying that all anal sex is gay sex. Someone asked me why I didn’t address the “cocksucker” lines when calling out Battlefield 3‘s homophobic multiplayer dialogue. “Somebody kill these cocksuckers!” or words to that effect is another one of the homophobic lines one might hear during a match. That’s a very clear example of homophobia because cocksucker, when used as an insult by one man against another man, is a gender-specific insult that unpacks into “Sucking cocks is bad.” Maybe I should have brought that line up instead of declining to do so out of fear of beating the reader over the head with my point. To argue that the lines “I’m getting fucked up the ass over here!” and “Fuck, I’m getting my shit pushed in here!” have nothing to do with homophobia when they are happening in the same space if not simultaneously with lines about wanting to “kill cocksuckers” is absurd. The reason why you cannot make the argument that these soldiers are only complaining about not wanting to mc888 be raped and remove homophobia from the equation is because in order to do so, you have to remove these lines of dialogue from the entire context in which they are set. Language doesn’t work like that. Context matters. If you want to understand what these lines of dialogue mean, you cannot isolate them from the fact that they are being issued by members of an organization which is institutionally homophobic, hence why Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell is a relevant context for analysis. Part of homophobia is fear on the part of straight men that gay men will not be able to control their sex urges and express sexual interest in them. This is why homophobic straight men get uncomfortable with the idea of sharing intimate space like showers, locker rooms—or military units—with “queers.” You also can’t refuse to hold these lines of Battlefield 3 multiplayer dialogue up to that contextual lens, either, if you want to argue that you fully understand what they mean. There is one other frequent response to Monday’s article that I’d like to address, namely that I am being over-sensitive. Having identified to you as being solidly outside the boundaries of where the injury from this sort of prejudice falls I hope I’ve blunted that idea in large part already. But then there’s my love of the word cocksucker. It can leap out of my mouth during a match of Battlefield 3 when someone snipes me from 100 yards away, or when I’m about to drop an M320 grenade into a crowd of enemy players and someone else runs me over riches888pg with a tank. “That fucking cocksucker!” I might yell jinda44 out, much to the amusement of the group of guys I play first person shooters with on Xbox Live. One night my friend Scott joined the Party Chat of my virtual band of brothers. I held off on the use of my favorite curse word because Scott is gay. I chose to be sensitive and not use a word that might have made him feel uncomfortable. I cringed every time someone in my Party said “That gun is so gay” when they were killed by a weapon which they felt was unbalanced, or “Someone kill this fag that just shot me.” I have to recognize that I was just as responsible for my friends’ language that night as they were, because it means fuck-all not to use the word cocksucker when Scott was around if I am going to use it when he isn’t. This isn’t about being over-sensitive, but just sensitive In the process of calling out the homophobic language in Battlefield 3‘s multiplayer I was calling myself out, as well, for my love of the word cocksucker and how profligate I can be with its use. Even if I’m only doing so within a closed Xbox Live Party chat, the simple humanity of not using that word shouldn’t go away just because no one who might be offended is around to hear
Reader Comments
The variety of games is excellent, including table games like blackjack, roulette, and baccarat, in addition to slots. This keeps the platform interesting and allows me to switch games depending on my mood. The payout process is generally smooth and reliable, though occasionally it takes longer than expected. Overall, I feel confident that my winnings are safe and will be credited properly.
The mobile interface is smooth and intuitive. I can play all my favorite slots on the go without experiencing any lag or glitches. The design is responsive and user-friendly, which makes gaming on my phone just as enjoyable as on my computer. The payout process is generally smooth and reliable, though occasionally it takes longer than expected. Overall, I feel confident that my winnings are safe and will be credited properly.
The mobile interface is smooth and intuitive. I can play all my favorite slots on the go without experiencing any lag or glitches. The design is responsive and user-friendly, which makes gaming on my phone just as enjoyable as on my computer. Customer support has been outstanding whenever I had any issues. They respond quickly and professionally, ensuring that any concerns with deposits, withdrawals, or gameplay are addressed immediately, which makes me trust the platform more. I love the overall aesthetic of the platform. The animations, visual effects, and sound design make the gaming experience more dynamic and immersive. It's one of the reasons I keep coming back.